Best Car Insurance Companies in Kenya in 2026: How to Compare the Right Fit
Choosing from a list of the best car insurance companies in Kenya can still leave you paying more than expected after an accident.
Your excess may be larger than you understood. Your vehicle’s actual use may fall outside the policy. A benefit you assumed was included may be optional.
There is no single best insurer for every driver. This guide compares eligibility, excesses, benefits, settlement terms and payment options to help you find the right fit.
Table of Contents
Which car insurance company is best in Kenya?
There is no single company that is best for every motorist.
A suitable insurer should pass six tests:
- It accepts your vehicle and its actual use.
- Its excess structure is affordable.
- Its free benefits have useful limits.
- The optional benefits you need are available.
- Its repair and settlement terms suit the vehicle.
- Its payment arrangement works for you.
Premium should be compared after these questions have been answered.
If you have not selected the appropriate level of cover, begin with our guide to the types of car insurance in Kenya
How Amssurity Assessed the Best Car Insurance Companies in Kenya
Our comparison of the best car insurance companies in Kenya focuses on information that can be verified in quotations, product documents and policy schedules.
We compared:
- Product eligibility
- Vehicle-age and value rules
- Private, ride-hailing and commercial-use acceptance
- Excesses
- Free and optional benefits
- Repair and settlement options
- Premium payment arrangements
- Claims-reporting support
Exact terms remain subject to the final quotation, valuation, policy schedule and underwriting approval.
Car insurance companies included in this comparison
The current Amssurity comparison panel includes:
- CIC General Insurance
- Fidelity Shield Insurance
- Heritage Insurance
- Intra Africa Assurance
- Old Mutual General Insurance
- Pioneer General Insurance
- SanlamAllianz General Insurance
This is a selected comparison panel rather than a list of every motor insurer in Kenya. The Insurance Regulatory Authority maintains the register of licensed insurers.
The insurers below are not ranked from best to worst. The best car insurance companies in Kenya for your shortlist will depend on whether they accept your vehicle, its actual use and the protection you need.
| Insurer | Current structure | Check before choosing |
|---|---|---|
| CIC Insurance | Comprehensive and third-party cover, with towing, motoring assistance, emergency medical, windscreen and entertainment benefits. | Eligibility, benefit limits, excesses and add-on prices. |
| Fidelity Insurance | Private-motor cover for personal and permitted business use. Hire-and-reward use is excluded. | Actual use, vehicle age, excesses and loss-of-use terms. |
| Heritage Insurance | Comprehensive terms for fresh imports and accident-free vehicles. Windscreen and radio limits are KSh 50,000 each. | Claims history, make or model, value, minimum premium and excess protector. |
| Intra Africa Assurance | Comprehensive cover based on vehicle make, model, age and value. | Eligibility list, applicable rate, excesses and add-ons. |
| Old Mutual Insurance | Third-party, fire and theft, and comprehensive cover, subject to the stated vehicle use. | Excesses, value rules, add-ons and settlement terms. |
| Pioneer Insurance | Third-party, fire and theft, and comprehensive cover, plus a separate electric-vehicle product. | Benefits, excesses, payment terms and electric-vehicle fit. |
| SanlamAllianz Insurance | Comprehensive cover with some benefits determined by vehicle value. | Applicable rate, excess protector and add-ons. |
Terms can change. Confirm vehicle eligibility, pricing and benefits in the final quotation and policy schedule.
Eligibility comes before premium
Insurers can apply different rules to the same vehicle.
Before comparing prices, establish whether each insurer accepts:
- The year of manufacture
- Current market value
- Make and model
- Condition and roadworthiness
- Previous claims history
- Actual vehicle use
- Ownership or insurable interest
- Applicable security requirements
Older vehicles, some vehicle models, previous claims and commercial use may reduce the available options or change the rate.
A low advertised rate has little value if it does not apply to your vehicle.
The right insurer cannot correct the wrong level of cover. If you are still deciding how much protection your vehicle needs, compare comprehensive and third-party car insurance in Kenya.
Private use is different from ride-hailing use
A private-motor policy normally covers the uses stated in the schedule, such as social, domestic, leisure and permitted personal-business use.
Ride-hailing, taxi, delivery and other hire-and-reward activities create a different risk. The actual use must be disclosed and accepted.
For example, Fidelity’s published motor-private proposal form excludes vehicles used for hire or reward. Other motor policies also rely on the limitations as to use shown in the policy schedule.
A private comprehensive certificate should therefore not be assumed to cover Uber, Bolt, Little Cab, paid passenger transport or commercial deliveries.
Compare these policy terms before the premium
1. Excesses
An excess is the portion of a covered loss that the policyholder must bear.
Check the excess applicable to:
- Accidental damage
- Theft
- Young or inexperienced drivers
- Unauthorised drivers
- Total loss
- Under-declaration of value
A quotation that is KSh 5,000 cheaper could produce a much higher cost after an accident if its excess is larger.
Our guide to how much car insurance costs in Kenya explains how rates, minimum premiums, statutory charges and optional benefits affect the final amount payable.
Excess protector can reduce or remove an applicable excess when the claim meets the policy conditions. Its price and availability vary by insurer and vehicle value.
Current Amssurity terms show this variation clearly. Intra Africa prices excess protector at 0.25% of vehicle value, subject to a KSh 5,000 minimum. Old Mutual applies 0.25%, minimum KSh 2,500, below KSh 3 million, while the reviewed structure includes it from KSh 3 million. SanlamAllianz applies 0.25%, minimum KSh 5,000, up to KSh 1.5 million and includes it above that value.
These figures should always be reconfirmed in the final quotation.
2. Free benefits
Comprehensive policies commonly include benefits such as:
- Windscreen
- Entertainment equipment
- Towing
- Emergency medical expenses
- Roadside assistance
The useful question is not whether the benefit appears on the quotation. Ask how much it covers.
A KSh 30,000 windscreen limit may be adequate for one vehicle and insufficient for another with specialised glass, cameras or sensors.
Check the monetary limit, number of permitted claims, applicable excess and whether the benefit must be reinstated after use.
3. Optional benefits
Common optional additions include:
- Excess protector
- Political violence and terrorism
- Courtesy car
- Loss of use
- Road rescue
- Enhanced windscreen
- Personal accident benefits
Courtesy car and loss of use should be examined separately.
Courtesy-car cover may provide a temporary replacement vehicle under defined circumstances. Loss-of-use cover usually pays a stated daily cash amount for a limited period.
Current Amssurity quotations include courtesy-car options priced at KSh 3,000 under CIC and Intra Africa. Old Mutual’s reviewed quotation applies KSh 3,000 for vehicles below KSh 3 million and KSh 8,000 above that value. Fidelity’s reviewed loss-of-use benefit pays KSh 3,000 per day for up to 10 days.
The claim trigger, waiting period and number of days must still be checked.
See our guide to motor insurance upgrades in Kenya for a closer look at excess protection, political violence, loss of use, courtesy car and road-rescue benefits.
Repair and settlement terms matter
Before buying comprehensive cover, ask what would happen after:
- Repairable accident damage
- A proposed cash settlement
- A total loss
Confirm whether repairs must use an approved garage, when an assessor becomes involved and whether work requires prior insurer approval.
For total loss, ask how the settlement will be calculated. The insured value should not automatically be treated as a guaranteed payout. The result may depend on pre-accident market value, underinsurance, applicable excess, outstanding premium, financier interest and salvage treatment.
These questions become particularly important for high-value, financed, rare or modified vehicles.
It is equally important to understand what happens after an incident. Our car insurance claims guide for Kenya explains the reporting, evidence, assessment and decision stages.
Can car insurance be paid in instalments?
Amssurity’s current motor panel generally supports a 40%–30%–30% payment arrangement, subject to insurer approval and the agreed payment dates.
Amssurity Insurance is also an appointed CIC agent and can arrange CIC Easy Bima for eligible private vehicles. Easy Bima allows the annual motor premium to be paid in up to 12 monthly instalments.
Before choosing instalments, confirm the initial deposit, due dates, total payable premium and what happens if an instalment is missed.
Why complaint statistics do not create a motor ranking
The IRA’s Q3 2025 Claims Settlement Report recorded 439 complaints across general insurance and classified 75.4% as delayed.
The report did not identify all those complaints as motor claims and does not provide a motor-insurer ranking. The figure therefore cannot establish that 75.4% of motor complaints involved delays or show which insurer settles motor claims faster.
Amssurity does not use that statistic to rank the companies in this guide. IRA Q3 2025 Claims Settlement Report.
Which insurer may fit your situation?
| Your situation | What to prioritise |
|---|---|
| Older vehicle | Age acceptance, valuation and excess. |
| Ride-hailing vehicle | Correct use class and protection against downtime. |
| High-value vehicle | Theft conditions, valuation and repair arrangements. |
| Financed vehicle | Financier requirements and total-loss settlement. |
| Electric vehicle | Battery, charging equipment and specialist repairs. |
| Daily-use vehicle | Courtesy car, loss of use, towing and roadside assistance. |
| Budget-sensitive buyer | Total premium, excess and payment arrangement. |
This is why the best car insurance companies in Kenya for an older private car may differ from those suitable for a financed, ride-hailing or electric vehicle.
Insurer fit only matters after you have chosen the appropriate level of protection. If you are still deciding, compare comprehensive and third-party car insurance in Kenya.
Eight questions to ask before accepting a quotation
- Does the insurer accept my vehicle and actual use?
- What excess would I pay?
- Is excess protector included?
- What are the free-benefit limits?
- Which benefits cost extra?
- How will repairs and total loss be handled?
- What happens if I miss an instalment?
- Who will support me during a claim?
Once these questions have been answered, our guide to buying car insurance in Kenya online explains the quotation, documentation, payment and certificate-issuance process.
Final verdict
When choosing among the best car insurance companies in Kenya, begin with eligibility rather than price. A low premium offers little value if the vehicle, its use or the protection you need falls outside the policy.
Compare the car insurance in Kenya premiums after the policy has passed those tests.
Amssurity helps you reduce the compare car insurance in Kenya and shortlist to eligible options and understand the differences before you pay.
Compare what the premium does not show
Get up to three eligible motor insurance options with a clear comparison of:
- Premium and payment structure
- Excesses
- Free benefit limits
- Optional-benefit costs
- Vehicle-use conditions
Prefer to message directly? 0762 065 500
Car Insurance FAQs
Which are the best car insurance companies in Kenya?
The right company depends on your vehicle’s age, value, make, use, claims history and required benefits. Compare eligibility and policy terms before comparing premiums.
Can an older vehicle get comprehensive insurance?
Some insurers accept older vehicles subject to valuation, roadworthiness, make, model and underwriting approval. Available options usually reduce as the vehicle gets older.
Does private car insurance cover Uber or Bolt?
Private cover should not be assumed to include ride-hailing. The actual use must be disclosed and accepted under the correct motor class or endorsement.
Last reviewed: 17 July 2026
Disclaimer: Motor rates, benefits, excesses and acceptance rules can change. Confirm the final quotation and policy schedule before purchase.
Founder & Insurance Advisor | Amssurity Insurance Agency, an IRA-licensed agency in Nairobi
Agnes Mukulu advises individuals, families, SMEs and diaspora Kenyans on health, motor, business, life and international medical insurance. Having reviewed hundreds of policies, quotations and benefit schedules, she helps clients look beyond premiums to understand benefits, exclusions, waiting periods, excesses and claims requirements. She founded Amssurity to make insurance guidance clearer, more transparent and more practical, helping clients choose suitable cover and understand how it should work when they need it most.